After three
years in the making and RIB give the shippers three seconds worth! Don’t get me
wrong, I’m glad it happened, I liked what I saw, I just wish there had been
more of it. And here is why:
1.
I
still hold a grudge with RIB for never showing enough Emma Pillsbury and
2.
Cutting
out the Wemma scene from ‘New York’ in Season 2 and
3.
Not fulfilling their promise of ‘hot Wemma action’ in season 3.
4.
But
ultimately because I don’t think the montage satisfactorily recognized Emma’s
achievement.
Emma, like
all the characters this season has battled her demons (OCD) and as Will and New
Directions individually and collectively conquered their demons and realized
their dreams throughout the course of Season 3, Emma was the only one left with
an unfulfilled ambition. Therefore
it was no surprise that sexual intercourse had to be on the agenda in one of
the final episodes. Like a lot of story lines in Glee, they take forever
suspending a resolution then deliver the resolution in a quick and snappy way or
off screen so it leaves you feeling unfulfilled and wondering why you placed
any emotional investment in the story in the first place. Wemma sex was no
exception. It happened off screen. Thanks RIB. THREE YEARS!
Should the
intercourse have happened after Nationals? Some believe no because it intimated
that Emma’s virginity was a ‘reward’ for Will. I beg to differ. Emma has wanted
to get physical with Will ever since ‘Hello’, but her OCD has stood in the way.
Over the course of Season 3 she has slowly beaten back the OCD and by this
episode stands on the brink of victory. She is inspired by Will’s success with
the Glee club, the kids winning, Sue winning. She wants to be a winner too. In
her mind, Will deserves to be with a winner and if anything motivates her to
succeed it’s wanting what’s best for Will. It’s why she denied her love for him
for so long, it’s why she told him to accept April’s offer. She wants to be the
best for him. Just as he wanted to show her how special she was when she won
tenure, she wants to show him how special he is winning Nationals. Therefore it
was the opportune time, her man of action has succeeded and he’s turned her on,
in a big way.
As Emma
stands before Will dressed in her cream coloured skirt and top, she holds up
the newspaper showing Will’s success on the front page, the pride is bursting
from her face and the phallic symbolism of the flowering candle opening up to
reveal the burning flame at Emma’s crotch was a metaphor for exactly how she
was feeling about Will – her loins are on fire with desire! Her virginity is
about to go up in flames. She’s caught up in the ecstasy of being a winner,
which is just the aphrodisiac she needs. Emma wants to prove herself a winner
too. Further symbolism was meant to convey Emma’s desire: the open curtains –
not quite meeting in the middle – the camera lingers on them after Wemma
disappear in hurry. Like the curtains, Emma is open for business. Her red
nightdress representing passion, lust, vigour. Emma is back-lit, making her
look like a flame burning with desire. The sped up footage conveyed their
unbridled passion for each other and the similar nightdress and choreography as
Emma’s fantasy in ‘Like a Virgin’ and ‘Toucha Toucha Me’ alluded to Emma’s
dream becoming a reality. Emma and Will are ‘Tongue Tied’, there are no words
left for them to express their love for each other, physicality can now say
more than words can. It’s an upbeat, celebratory song about friendship and love
and not wanting to let go of the euphoria that love and friendship brings. ‘I
loved you then and I love you now’, succinctly wraps up their journey. Emma’s
reason for wanting sex was delivered via film techniques but symbolism and
allusion did not quite fulfil the emotional needs of this Wemma fan.
Then we got
the following dialogue:
Will: Hey,
thank you.’
Emma: It
was my pleasure, literally. I just thought, you know, my man is a winner and he
deserves to be treated as such. And it was as much for me as it was for you.
Will: Last
night was, well worth the wait, but I meant thank you for everything. This
whole year has been incredible and I am so grateful to have you by my side.
Emma: Many
more years to come.
Of all the
polished verbal gems that Wemma have delivered over the years, this wasn’t one
of them. Only Wemma shippers would realize Emma’s motive and meaning in the
line ‘I did it for me as much as for you.’ That line was meant to convey the
magnitude of Emma’s achievement but it failed because it was overshadowed by
‘My pleasure, literally’ (we’re glad it went well!) and Will not responding to
the line. Of course she did it for her, she’s been battling her OCD her whole
life, it has been a cross to bear, of course she wants to get physical with
Will - she loves him, she wants his children. This was a monumental achievement
for Emma and it was rushed over. Just as the camera lingered on the faces of
Will and the kids after their win showing their satisfaction and happiness at
their success and then on Sue’s face at getting her Cheerios back, there should
have been a shot of Emma’s face post coitus. It’s a fine line to tread, celebrating
her achievement and not making a big deal of the sex because their relationship
is so much more than that. The love they have for each other is profound which
is reflected in Will’s response, ‘Last night was well worth the wait, but I meant
thank you for everything…’ But it was a monumental step in their relationship
and in Emma controlling her OCD and Will said nothing! Perhaps Will should have
said, ‘I’m proud of you or I know how hard it’s been for you but you did it’,
or words to that effect before he said ‘thank you for everything’. The writing
downplayed Emma’s achievement and left room for misinterpretation and that is
why I feel slightly let down by the end result.
Final
complaint: Sue interrupting their kiss. I guess Rachel was busy warming up her
voice!
On to other thoughts about the Wemma
scenes:
This
episode paid homage to so many golden Wemma moments in past episodes it was
almost a ‘Best of Wemma’ episode:
·
Emma
counselling and reassuring Will
·
Emma
watching Will break up fighting kids
·
The
Wemma hug
·
Emma
wrapping her hands around Will’s hand to calm his nerves as he had clasped hers
in ‘Asian F’. He kisses her in gratitude just as she had kissed him in
gratitude.
·
Emma
undressing Will
·
Will
spinning Emma around in yet another of her glorious nightdresses.
·
Emma
and Will sitting side by side watching the kids perform.
·
The
Wemma deep and meaningful
·
The
interrupted Wemma kiss.
·
Another
Pillsbury Pamphlet conveying a personal message.
·
Swaying
together to the music
·
Lots
of hand holding (they just can’t get close enough to each other)
·
The
Wemma look of love (so many adoring looks my heart melted)
·
Kisses
In conclusion:
Wemma
mirror each other’s actions, guide each other’s thoughts; they are synchronized
and physically attached. They forgive each other’s flaws, they reward each
other’s achievements; they inspire and delight each other. They share mind,
heart and soul. Wemma have become
one entity that radiates a love so divine that the shippers are entranced and cannot
resist the pull to board the ship for Season 4.
In
‘Goodbye’ as Rachel’s train departs, she stares at Finn down on the platform,
unable to reach him, separated by a glass window and a moving train. These are metaphors - life is
taking her in another direction and her dream is a barrier that cannot be
surmounted by Finn. He runs alongside the moving train, letting go of love.
Behind Finn stand Will and Emma secure in each other’s arms, smiling and (Emma
gives Will one of her looks of adoration) waving Rachel goodbye. They have
overcome all obstacles that stood in their way. Emma is even wearing the
clothes that represent her obstacles: the bow – her virginity/fear of sex; the
yellow jacket – not confronting her OCD (she wore it to hide from Will the ‘Ginger’ tshirt she was
wearing, instead of the OCD tshirt she should have had on); and the skirt she wore
when she stormed out of Figgin’s office and was living in denial about her love
for Will. Wemma are what Finchel could be
in the future. The contrast of the two couples was poignant and once again
highlighted parallels. As Will said to Emma at the end of Rocky Horror, ‘If I
really love you I have to let you go, for now,’ Finn said the same to Rachel.
Finn and Rachel are embarking on their journey, destination unknown. Will and
Emma have been on their journey and arrived at their destination: each other.
In true
Glee style let’s end on a song by Van Morrison:
‘There’s a
love that’s divine
And It’s
yours and It’s mine, like the sun…
And have I
told you lately that I love you?
Have I told
you there’s no one else above you?
You fill my
heart with gladness
You take
away all my sadness


I just want to say I have enjoyed reading all your wemma thoughts. Each time I've seen you post a new one on tumblr I get excited. Of course, whenever I watch the episode, many things come to mind, but you bring up things I don't think of, which is ultimately why I like reading your posts. For example, you mentioned all the wemma scenes in 'Nationals' that were shown in homage to past Wemma scenes. I had never thought about that until you pointed them out. Also, I've known about the Wemma/Finchel parallel, but you seem to have put it into new light for me. The only thing I caught in 'Goodbye', was that Finn was letting Rachel go to New York to chase her dreams like Emma had done to Will last season. I hope throughout the summer and into next season, you keep posting things like this because I have learned so much more about Wemma because of them. I had never seen things about them the way you see them and now I do. Now, I know and truly believe they belong together and as Emma said, I hope they last for many more years to come! Thank you, thank you!
ReplyDeleteThat's the nicest comment I've ever received! Thank you, and I'm glad you enjoy my Wemma thoughts. I fell in love with Will and Emma in the very first episode and when I realised how RIB were using film and literary devices to convey additional information to viewers I became completely obsessed. The show infuriates me sometimes but my passion for Wemma is constant. Over your summer (and my winter) I will be posting 'The Emma Pillsbury Diary: Season 3'. I hope it will be a fun read and a way to relive the Wemma journey from Emma's perspective. As long as RIB stay true to Wemma in season 4 I will continue to write about them.
ReplyDeleteAll the best.
You're so welcome and you completely deserve it! I have loved them from the beginning myself, but like I said it has grown to a whole new level now. It makes me mad too, but for some reason I keep tuning in each week to watch. The only thing I can think of is that I'm a less high maintenance Rachel Berry so I relate really well. Then of course, I love Jayma so as long as she is on Glee, I will watch! Oh good to hear! I've read the first two and now that you are planning on starting the third one, I can't wait to read it! Seeing things from her point of view is always more interesting than Will's. Here's hoping they do stay true to them, but I have a gut feeling we will see less and less of them especially since it's going to be a show within a show. Thank you and enjoy your winter! :D
ReplyDeleteI loved reading your "wemma" analysis and think you are spot on with everything that you said."they are synchronized and physically attached"...couldn't have said it better myself. Now that they have taken that next step...I really think there is so much we have to look foward to and I certainly hope RIB doesn't disappoint. We are entranced with their love story and I wish it wasn't overshadowed the way that it is. I hope all of the foreshadowing mentioned in S3 comes true in S4. Well written commentary! Looking forward to more of your posts. =)
ReplyDelete